Randolph L. Braham: The Reinterment and Political Rehabilitation of Miklós Horthy

It was twenty years ago, on September 3, 1993, that Miklós Horthy, regent of Hungary between 1920 and 1944, was reburied in Kenderes, the Horthy family’s ancestral home. The reinterment was controversial, mostly because half of the cabinet of Prime Minister József Antall attended the ceremony as “private persons.” 

Since then there have been sporadic efforts to rewrite the history of the Horthy era. In the last three years the Hungarian government has upped the ante, quietly but steadily encouraging a full rehabilitation of Miklós Horthy despite official denials of any such attempt. About a year ago in Washington Foreign Minister János Martonyi categorically denied any attempt at a rehabilitation of either Horthy or his regime. But the rehabilitation continues. For example, the twentieth anniversary of the reburial was remembered in Kenderes a couple of weeks ago. On that occasion Sándor Lezsák, deputy speaker of the Hungarian parliament, gave a laudatory speech about the former governor. According to him, “The [1993] reburial was a historical atonement, but we cannot be satisfied with that. Even after twenty years, the results of the hypnotizing effects of the poisonous lies of the socialist-communist four decades are still with us.” In his speech Lezsák accused “the historical criminals” who are back and who tried to remove important documents from the archives in an attempt to falsify history. He suggested setting up a research institute for the study of Miklós Horthy and his family. The institute would be a central depository of all documents relating to the Horthys.

Below is a short article by Randolph L. Braham, the renowned historian of the Hungarian Holocaust, entitled “The Reinterment and Political Rehabilitation of Miklós Horthy.” It appeared in Slavic Almanach, vol. 2, edited by Henrietta Mondry and Paul Schweiger (Johannesburg: University of the Witwatersrand, 1993), pp. 137-40. Professor Braham predicted twenty years ago that the full rehabilitation of Miklós Horthy would occur not too far in the future. I thank Professor Braham for allowing Hungarian Spectrum to republish this article.

* * *

The remains of Miklós Horthy, the former Regent of Hungary (1920-1944), were brought back from Portugal and reinterred in his hometown of Kenderes on 4 September 1993, together with those of his wife and youngest son.* Hungarian nationalists all over the world will undoubtedly hail the former head of state as a patriot who successfully championed the twin causes of anti-communism and revisionism. They will recall that during his rule, the country evolved along a nationalist-Christian line and made great strides towards the reestablishment of Greater Hungary by reacquiring some of the territories that were lost under the peace treaties of Trianon (1920). But was he really a patriot?

Horthy and HitlerHorthy was a representative of the conservative-aristocratic elite that perpetuated an anachronistic semi-feudal class system. His domestic policies aimed at preserving the privileges of the landowning aristocracy and stifling the aspirations of the peasantry. In foreign affairs, his primary objective was to bring about “the revision of the punitive peace treaties”–a policy that led to Hungary’s adherence to the Axis and the establishment of an authoritarian proto-fascist regime. Horthy’ s Hungary embraced Hitler’s revisionist ambitions and was the first among the Nazi satellite states to sign the Tripartite Pact (20 November 1941). Having joined the Axis aggression first against Yugoslavia (11 April 1941),and then against the Soviet Union (27 June 1941), Hungary soon found itself at war with the Western democracies as well. After the crushing defeat of the Hungarian and German armies at Voronezh and Stalingrad early in 1943, the Horthy regime aimed to bring about the gradual extrication of Hungary from the Axis Alliance. But the pursuit of unattainable goals–the retention of the reacquired territories, the avoidance of a Soviet occupation, and the possible preservation of the “traditional system”–led to disaster: Hungary was first occupied by the Germans (19 March 1944) and then by the Red Army. Horthy himself was ousted on 15-16 October, in a coup engineered by the Hungarian Nazi radicals acting in conjunction with the Germans. Under the new “Hungarist” regime, Hungary became the only Nazi satellite to fight to the very end and, consequently, once again emerged as a major loser after World War II.

Disastrous as Horthy’ s domestic and foreign policies may have been for the country at large, they proved catastrophic for Hungarian Jewry. They contributed to, if not actually determined, the virtual destruction of the loyal and highly patriotic Jewish community that contributed disproportionately to the modernization of the country. It was during Horthy’ s tenure that the once flourishing Jewish community was subjected to increasingly severe discriminatory measures that led to its decline and eventual destruction. Like the other members of the aristocratic-conservative elite, Horthy was a “civilized” anti-Semite, who was particularly scornful of the “Eastern,” unassimilated Jews. Shortly after he was named commander-in-chief of the counter-revolutionary national forces in 1919, several units of the army engaged in pogroms that claimed thousands of Jewish lives. Almost immediately after his inauguration as Regent, Hungary adopted the first anti-Jewish law in post-World War I Europe (22 September 1920). This was followed by increasingly harsh laws in the late 1930s. In the summer of 1941, from 16,000 to 18,000 so-called “alien” Jews were deported to near Kamenets-Podolsk, where most of them were slaughtered by the Nazis. Early in 1942, close to one thousand Jews were murdered in the Bácska area by Hungarian gendarmerie and military units. Tens of thousands of Jews later died while serving in forced labour companies.

While it is true that in contrast to those in Nazi-ruled Europe, the Jews of Hungary were relatively well off, the ever harsher anti-Jewish measures of the late 1930s prepared the ground for the acceptance and successful implementation of the Final Solution programme after the German occupation. During his Schloss Klessheim meeting with Hitler on 18-19 March 1944, Horthy gave his consent to the delivery of several hundred thousand “Jewish workers” to Germany. The German and Hungarian experts on the Final Solution took full advantage of this agreement to carry out their ideologically defined racial objectives. After the inauguration of the Horthy-appointed government of Döme Sztójay, the Jewish community of Hungary was subjected to the most ruthless and concentrated destruction process of the war. With the instruments of state power at their disposal, the Nazis and their Hungarian accomplices succeeded in “solving” the Jewish question at lightning speed. The isolation, expropriation, ghettoization, concentration and deportation of the Jews–anti-Jewish measures that took years to carry out in Poland–were implemented in less than four months. On 7 July, Horthy halted the deportations (they in fact continued until 9 July), but by then all of Hungary, with the notable exception of Budapest, was already Judenrein. The Holocaust in Hungary claimed close to 600,000 victims.

Horthy’ s admirers will, no doubt, remember primarily his halting of the deportation in connection with the Hungarian Holocaust. But even at that late hour, Horthy apparently did not act on his own initiative. He was subjected to great political and moral pressure by Pope Pius XII, King Gustav of Sweden, and other Western leaders who were informed of the grisly details of the Holocaust in Hungary. Influential as these pressures may have been, perhaps the determining factor that induced Horthy to act was the rapidly deteriorating military situation. The Red Army was fast approaching Hungary, and the Western Allies were already fanning out in France after their successful landing in Normandy. While the Jews of Budapest may have been saved by Horthy–a credit also claimed by the Raoul Wallenberg myth-makers and even by the German and Hungarian Nazis–the Jews of the Hungarian countryside, including those of the territories acquired from Czechoslovakia, Romania and Yugoslavia, were liquidated during Horthy’ s tenure. And this took place on the eve of Allied victory, when the secrets of Auschwitz were already widely known.

Hungary’s disasters notwithstanding, contemporary chauvinists will continue to remember-and admire Horthy’ s blend of conservative anti-communism and militant nationalism. The reinterment of his remains is likely to emerge as the first step towards his full rehabilitation as a “patriot” who tried to advance Hungary’s best interests as he perceived them to be. In a series of interviews, Prime Minister József Antall identified Horthy as a “Hungarian patriot” who should be placed into the community of the nation and the awareness of the people.” The national mint issued a commemorative medal with Horthy’ s likeness. The reburial ceremony was attended by tens of thousands of Hungarians, many of whom were presumably longing for the return to the “good old days” of the Horthy era. Among those attending as “private citizens” were four leading members of the government, including the Minister of Justice, István Balsai, and the Minister of the Interior, Péter Boross.

Judging by the events surrounding the reinterment of Horthy’s remains, rehabilitation will probably be all but complete in the not-too-distant future. It is the task of objective historians concerned for Hungary’s soul and democratic future to keep the record straight.

——

*Miklós Horthy died in Estoril on 9 February 1957, at age 88. His son, Miklós Jr., died on 28 March 1993, at age 86. They were buried together with Mrs. Horthy, who died in 1959, in the English Cemetery in Lisbon.

Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Julianna bika
Guest

Sent from my iPad

spectator
Guest

An expressive comment regarding the efforts of the present government – I’ve heard recently;
“They’re trying to lick clean the Horthy regime”
Pretty accurate, as I see it.

Meanwhile, there are countless memorials, statues, even his picture on the city-sign(!) – the cult alive and well, thank you.

Hungary, 2013.
(I bet, you wouldn’t believe it if only look around there, I promise!)

Jano
Guest
As I see it, the problem is not so much with Horthy as a person. He probably indeed felt he was acting as a patriot as horribly and tragically misguided as he was. I am not even sure if he could have actually done anything more to improve the situation, but of course he certainly could have opted for resignation and saved his name by not caving in to Hitler’s dictatum at Schloss Klessheim. (Although in his mind, he probably thought that as governor he might be able to do more than as a prisoner in Germany). The governor wasn’t running a one man show, and as Eva pointed it out many posts ago, he was very volatile and susceptible for manipulation by his surroundings. I think he is a far more complicated historical personality to be categorized as pure evil or true patriot, even though one tends to like these extremes. The real problem is with the attempt to rehabilitate the Horthy period, the accepted public (definitely anti-semitic) attitude of the era in which the desire reacquisition of the lost territories overwrote every rational thought. In my opinion this is the right’s version of the good old days (very… Read more »
Guest

You shouldn’t forget that Horthy was a product of the Austrian military system – I read somewhere that he spoke German more fluently than Hungarian, is that true ?

And the feudal system in Austria and Hungary surely was a big factor – and the decadency of the whole kuk monarchy, aristocracy and military as described by Karl Kraus – and of course Hašek and his brave soldier Švejk (one of my favourite books and the film and the tv series are also very good)…

PS and a bit OT:
Is Karl Kraus also a household name in Hungary ?

Shaemus
Guest

wolfi: no, Karl Kraus is not a household name in Hungary.

btw: http://www.theguardian.com/books/2013/sep/13/jonathan-franzen-wrong-modern-world

I am not sure what time horizon (“not too distant future”) Braham meant. In 20 years, however, a real rehabilitation fortunately did not take place.

Sure enough, many aspects of the era is being revived (see Kossuth square, Klebelsberg plan etc.), the extreme right and the Christian (for foreigners, it means non-Jewish) middle class of Buda loves Horthy, but there is no real rehabilitation, neither is an official cult. I think a cult of Horthy would compete with the cult of Orbán and more pragmatically a more overt Horthy mania could unite the more liberal and future oriented people. So it seems to me that Horthy continues to be quite controversial.

Guest

wolfi: ” the decadency of the whole kuk monarchy, aristocracy and military as described by Karl Kraus – and of course Hašek and his brave soldier Švejk”.

Don’t forget Musil: Der Mann ohne Eigenschaften.

PerestroikaHU
Guest

Reconciliation between the Hungarian people is an important task.
Each political era was served by a large civil service staff.
The Horthy civil servants were as brainwashed as the Orban era servants, or the Rakosi/Kadar era.
All of them, or their loyal survivors should educate themselves to liberate themselves from their shackles.
Together, and with the partners in the new Europe, there must be a path out of the dead end streets of the past.
Orbanism is a setback.
The Hungarian reconstruction/Hungarian perestroika must be achieved with tender loving care.

Karl Pfeifer
Guest

When my friend György Gadó spoke in Hungarian parliament (1990-1994) against the tolerance for Nazi and the new Horthy cult he was attacked not only by the extreme right wing antisemites around Csurka but also by SZDSZ politicians like TGM Miklós Tamás Gábor.
In 1996 János Kis advocated in Népszabadság tolerance for Nazi speech.
They were convinced that Hungary needs a first amendment and forgot, that the USA had a long tradition of free speech, while in Hungary more than half a million citizens were sent by a government installed by Horthy to be killed in Auschwitz-Birkenau. And that even after the liberation of Hungary pogroms took place.

NewBeginning2013
Guest

Karl Pfeifer:”They were convinced that Hungary needs a first amendment and forgot, that the USA had a long tradition of free speech, while in Hungary more than half a million citizens were sent by a government installed by Horthy to be killed in Auschwitz-Birkenau. And that even after the liberation of Hungary pogroms took place.”

Hungary needs Enlightenment.
Our own Ferenc Deak could be the model.
In good case, 10% of Hungarians would really embrace the principles of Deak.
Non-violence, non-prejudice, universal justice….

The mass of bad impulses has to be purged by the future new leaders.

tappanch
Guest

September 16, 2013 is a sad day. Today a fidesznik filled in the last independent position of the state – that of the ombudsman.

Yes, there are still some independent-minded judges – but they will not be promoted by Orban’s personal friend and they know this.

One can call the system a one-party state from now on, even if there are still other parties.

Do not forget, GDR, Poland and Czechoslovakia had nominally multiparty systems before 1990, and all Communist countries had nominal elections.

tappanch
Guest

The fifth Fidesz tinkering with their own “basic law” can be found here:

http://www.parlament.hu/irom39/12015/12015.pdf

Kirsten
Guest

tappanch:”Do not forget, GDR, Poland and Czechoslovakia had nominally multiparty systems before 1990, and all Communist countries had nominal elections.”

… and in all these countries, people rebelled eventually…

Karl Pfeifer
Guest

Kirsten :
tappanch:”Do not forget, GDR, Poland and Czechoslovakia had nominally multiparty systems before 1990, and all Communist countries had nominal elections.”
… and in all these countries, people rebelled eventually…

the Horthyregime tolerated until March 19, 1944 the socialdemocratic party and the Hungarian people did not rebell.
Today Hungary being member of EU those inclined to rebell can leave easily the country and settle in Europe elsewhere.
As long as the Orbán regime is playing the “national” card, and as long as the majority of Hungarian opposition is what it is, Orbán and his ilk can sleep well.

Emery Berczellewr, M.D.
Guest
Emery Berczellewr, M.D.

The ” Military Channel” frequently films from the Hitler era where you can see Horthy visiting German military installations with Hitler. Horthy boasted to Hitler that his government was the first after WWI who introduced anti-Jewish laws. (The infamous “Numerus Clausus”, limiting the number of Jews who could enter as students into Universities and other higher scientific institutes.)

wpDiscuz